How To Select Equivalent HPLC Columns: For Accurate Analysis

Introduction and Background

Equivalent HPLC columns play an important role during analysis when the column mentioned in the analytical method is not available. However, selecting equivalent columns is a challenging task for any chromatographer as it requires knowledge of chemistry as well as skill. In this article, you will learn about equivalent HPLC columns and its selection process, along with case studies and FAQs

Equivalent HPLC Columns

Alternative HPLC columns (of different makes) having the same stationary phase chemistry, particle size, porosity, and dimensions (length and diameter) as the original columns described in the monograph are called equivalent columns.

You may like: How to Control Impurities in Pharmaceuticals?

Selection Procedure of Equivalent HPLC Columns

Several factors are considered while selecting the equivalent column. The following is an 8 step guide to deciding on an equivalent column for HPLC analysis:

1. Understand the Original Column’s Properties

• Stationary Phase: Identify the type of stationary phase in your original column (e.g., C18, C8, phenyl, cyano, etc.). The stationary phase greatly influences the separation mechanism (e.g., reverse phase, normal phase, ion-exchange, size exclusion, etc.).
• Particle Size: The particle size of the stationary phase affects column efficiency. Smaller particles (e.g., 3-5 µm) provide better resolution and faster separations, but they require higher pressure.
• Column Dimensions: The length (mm), internal diameter (mm), and particle size all contribute to the separation and efficiency of the column. Ensure that the equivalent column matches these parameters for consistency.
• Pore Size: For large molecules, the pore size (in Ångströms) should be considered. A larger pore size (e.g., 300-500 Å) is needed for separating larger compounds.

2. Consider the Separation Mode

• Reverse Phase (RP): If the original column is a reverse-phase column (e.g., C18), look for a column with similar C18 or other alkyl chains.
• Normal Phase: If your analysis involves normal-phase chromatography (e.g., silica or amino columns), choose an equivalent silica-based column.
• Ion-Exchange: If you are working with charged analytes (e.g., proteins, amino acids, etc.), select an ion-exchange column with similar stationary phase characteristics (e.g., sulfonic acid for cation-exchange, quaternary amines for anion-exchange).
• Size Exclusion: If size exclusion chromatography (SEC) is used, choose a column with the same or similar pore size to match the molecular weight range of your analytes.

3. Matching Selectivity and Retention

• Retention Factor (k’): A similar stationary phase with comparable hydrophobicity will provide similar retention for analytes. If your analytes are hydrophobic, choosing a C18 or C8 column would typically ensure similar retention times.
• Selectivity: Selectivity is determined by both the stationary phase and the mobile phase. Columns with different functional groups (e.g., C8 vs. C18) can give different selectivities for polar or non-polar compounds. Choose an equivalent column that matches the selectivity of the original.
• Mobile Phase Compatibility: Ensure that the new column is compatible with your mobile phase. For example, if you are using high organic solvents in reverse-phase chromatography, ensure that the equivalent column can tolerate them.

4. Column Compatibility with Instrumentation

• Pressure Limits: Check the pressure limits of the equivalent column. Smaller particles or longer columns may result in higher backpressure, so ensure that your HPLC system can accommodate these requirements.
• Flow Rate: Ensure the flow rate of the equivalent column matches the capabilities of your system. Flow rate impacts resolution and analysis time.

5. Evaluate Manufacturer Specifications

• If you’re looking for an “equivalent” column, manufacturers often provide guidelines on column equivalency. For example, an equivalent column to an Agilent ZORBAX C18 might be a Thermo Scientific Hypersil GOLD C18 or Waters XBridge C18.

6. Column Length and Internal Diameter

• Length (mm): The length affects separation resolution and analysis time. Shorter columns (e.g., 50-100 mm) are faster but may provide lower resolution, while longer columns (e.g., 150 mm or more) give better resolution but require longer analysis times.
• Internal Diameter (ID): The internal diameter of the column affects the sample load and the separation efficiency. A smaller ID (e.g., 2.1 mm) offers higher resolution for small sample amounts but may need a lower flow rate and more sensitivity. Larger columns (e.g., 4.6 mm) are often used for higher sample loads.

7. Evaluate the Sample Characteristics

• Polarity: The polarity of the analytes affects which type of stationary phase will be most effective (e.g., C18 for hydrophobic compounds).
• Molecular Weight: If your sample contains large molecules (e.g., proteins, polymers), consider using a size exclusion column.
• Charge: For charged compounds, ion-exchange columns are the most suitable.

8. Testing and Method verification

• Use equivalent column during method validation in robustness test.

Example:

If you are using a C18 reverse-phase column, here’s how you might choose an equivalent:

• Column Type: Reverse-phase (RP)
• Stationary Phase: C18 (octadecylsilane) or similar (C8, C4, etc.)
• Particle Size: Match particle size (e.g., 3 µm, 5 µm) to the original column for similar performance.
• Column Dimensions: Match length (e.g., 150 mm) and internal diameter (e.g., 4.6 mm).

Common Equivalent Columns:

• Agilent ZORBAX Eclipse XDB-C18 → Thermo Scientific Hypersil GOLD C18
• Phenomenex Luna C18 → Agilent ZORBAX Eclipse C18, Shimadzu Shim-pack C18

Conditions for Using Equivalent Column

• Elution pattern: The equivalent column should give the same peaks elution pattern as the original column.
• Separation mechanism: The equivalent column should give the same peaks separation pattern as the original column.
• System suitability acceptance criteria: The equivalent column should pass the system suitability acceptance criteria as mentioned in the monograph or STP.
• Detectability of the peak/Sensitivity: Impurities must be detected in the equivalent column same as original column

Conclusion

Selecting an equivalent HPLC column involves considering the column’s stationary phase, particle size, pore size, and dimensions. I hope this article has helped you understand equivalent HPLC column and its importance. You may also want to check out other articles on my blog such as:

• How to remove ghost peaks?

FAQs

What is prodigy ODS 3 column equivalent to?

You can use Inertsil® 3μ ODS-3

References:

• Equivalent Column Selection in HPLC